Glen Park Tavern Menu
44 items in 7 sections · $8.50 – $23.95 · Restaurant in Williamsville, NY
Glen Park Tavern’s menu lists 44 dishes and drinks, grouped into Let’s Start!, Tavern Dinners, Salads, From the Carving Station, Seafood, and Tavern Sandwiches and more. Prices range from $8.50 to $23.95, and a typical item costs about $17.95. Popular choices include Main Street Meatloaf, Classic Cobb (GF), Hand Carved Turkey Sandwich, Lobster Bisque, and Our Fabulous Fish Fry.
Let’s Start! 8
- Lobster Bisque
We are famous for this one! | Cup: $7.95 • Bowl: $10.95
- Oh La La French Onion Soup
A Tavern favorite that begins with sherry. Need I say more! | Cup: $7.95 • Bowl: $9.95
- Artichoke Dip (V)$14.95
Artichoke and spinach simmered in a three-cheese sauce and served with toasted garlic bread. Our dip is considered generous and chunky
- Chicken Quesadilla$15.95
Deliciously grilled chicken piled on a large flour shell with tomato, black olives, lettuce and cheddar cheese, then grilled
- Charlie’s Fresh Cut Chicken Fingers
A Tavern favorite of Charles! So tender my God Child Charlie devours them; the Best chicken fingers you have ever had. Fresh chicken tenders, dipped in tavern-made panko bread crumb mix, lightly fried & tossed with your choice of delicious
- Fresh Cut Tavern Fries (V)
A basket of our cut fresh, every morning fries. Served with your choice of our tavern made honey butter (great with the sweet fries), blue cheese, or gravy | Sweet Fries: $12.75 • French Fries: $6.95 • Tavern Chips $5.95
- Hot Stuffed Peppers (V)$17.95
Famous throughout the Village. When available we get fresh peppers from farmer Ken at Seabert Farms and stuff them with our secret mix of three cheeses, garlic, basil and breadcrumbs and drizzle them with olive oil
- Yummy Tavern Wings
Delicious plump wings tossed in our tavern made sauces!SAUCES: Mild, Medium, Hot, BBQ, Citrus Chipotle (+$0.50), Cajun (+$0.75), Sicilian (+$0.75), Honey Jerk (+$0.75) | 8 / MKTP, 12 / MKTP, 18 / MKTP
Tavern Dinners 4
- Main Street Meatloaf$17.95
Aunt Carole’s yummy meatloaf recipe is a classic. Fresh Certified Angus Beef ground chuck mixed with onions and spices and topped with gravy. Perfect dish to lift your spirits. Served with choice of potato and fresh steamed vegetables
- Hand Carved Beef or Turkey Dinner$20.95
Choose between our thinly sliced Prime C.A.B. beef or our succulent turkey breast. Either way you can’t go wrong. Both served with choice of potato and fresh veggie. Oh and, of course, what would a turkey dinner be without stuffing
- Tavern Baby Back Ribs
Jim Grenauer’s favorite dish. He worked for years to perfect the preparation and sauces for this recipe. Tender baby back ribs are boiled in the Grenauer family seasoning then grilled, topped with our tavern cannonball BBQ sauce. Served wit
- The William Mattar$21.95
4 Wings • 4 oz. Weck • 4 oz. Fries | This dish found its inspiration from Williamsville’s own William Mattar LLC. This infamous platter includes 4 jumbo chicken wings dressed in the sauce of your choice, a 4-ounce Beef on Weck and 4 ounces
Salads 4
- Classic Cobb (GF)$17.95
We have made this yummy California classic salad our own. Beginning with fresh grilled chicken and adding crumbly bleu cheese, black olives, crisp crumbled bacon, crumbled egg, fresh avocado and tomato beautifully arranged a top fresh mixed
- Greek Souvlaki$17.95
Chef tops fresh mixed greens (from Farmer Ken when available) with marinated grilled chicken along with black olives, fresh tomatoes, chopped red onion, feta, peppers and pepperoncini served with our very own tavern made Greek dressing
- Crystal Beach Cobb (GF)$20.95
All the goodies as our classic Cobb salad, minus the chicken. We use real crab meat instead
- Hail to The Tavern Caesar$12.95
Who doesn’t love this classic? We start with fresh crisp romaine lettuce and we toss it with tavern made croutons and Parmesan cheese and top with fresh tomatoes | Anchovies +$1.50 • Salmon +$8.95 | Fresh Chicken Breast Grilled or Cajun +$7
From the Carving Station 3
- Hand Carved Turkey Sandwich$16.95
Juicy fresh sliced turkey breast on a Costanzo’s roll served with a side of cranberry sauce. Served with tavern made chips
- Hot Roast Beef or Turkey Sandwich$17.95
Piled high on your choice of bread with gravy, mashed potatoes or tavern-made French fries Served with tavern made fries
- Buffalo’s Beef on Weck
Our signature dish – We serve Prime Certified Angus Beef on our tavern made Kummelweck roll from Costanzo’s sliced thin and piled high. Served with tavern made chips | Large $20.95 • Med $17.95 • Small $14.95
Seafood 5
- Our Fabulous Fish Fry
Our high standards in fish selection makes this the best fish fry you have ever had. Fresh cod dipped in our tavern made beer batter and lightly fried. Served with coleslaw, tavern-made macaroni salad and potato. Comes with your choice of p
- Fresh-Caught Broiled Fish$22.95
A healthier option to our classic fish fry. Light and flakey cod broiled with lemon. Served with coleslaw, tavern made macaroni salad and potato. Comes with your choice of potato
- Cajun Cod$22.95
We broil this tender fish topped with our tavern made Cajun spice. Served with coleslaw, tavernmade macaroni salad. Comes with your choice of potato
- Whitefish Francais$22.95
This fish will melt in your mouth. Fresh fish sautéed golden brown in our tavern Parmesan egg batter and topped with a garlic, lemon wine sauce
- Asiago Crusted Whitefish$22.95
A Tavern favorite. Generous portion of fresh cod crusted with asiago cheese and pan seared to perfection
Tavern Sandwiches 14
- The Glen Park Signature Burger
Grill it to your liking and top it with fresh lettuce and tomato served on a Costanzo roll | 12 oz. for $16.95 • 8 oz. for $15.95
- Grilled Chicken Sandwich$14.95
A tavern staple. Fresh chicken grilled or Cajun grilled served on a Costanzo roll topped with melted sharp cheese, fresh lettuce and tomato
- Grilled Chicken & Hot Stuffed Pepper$17.95
Fresh chicken grilled or Cajun grilled served on a Costanzo roll with melted asiago cheese, fresh lettuce and tomato topped with one of our famous hot stuffed peppers. I dare you...
- Chicken Finger Wrap$15.95
Our tavern made chicken fingers tossed in your choice of sauce – hot, medium, mild, citrus, chipotle or BBQ wrapped in a large flour tortilla with our tavern blue cheese, fresh lettuce and tomato
- The Glen Park Clubber$15.95
Our signature CLASSIC club piled high with hand carved turkey, crisp bacon, fresh lettuce and tomato then topped with mayo. Served on your choice of bread
- Gouda Burger$18.95
Our customer’s favorite 12 oz burger grilled to your liking and topped with melted Gouda cheese, sautéed onions, crisp bacon with fresh lettuce and tomato served on a Costanzo roll
- Fried Bologna Sandwich$14.95
This classic is served just like you remember with sautéed onions and provolone
- Reist Street Reuben$17.95
Fresh cooked corned beef piled high on marbled rye. Topped with sauerkraut, swiss cheese and our very own tavern made thousand island dressing
- The Garrison$23.95
One of our signature sandwiches! 6 oz. of tenderloin filet prepared to perfection on tavern garlic toast and served with your choice of tavern made fries or chips. Choose from sautéed mushrooms and onions with provolone or spinach
- Sacre Bleu Burger!$18.95
This decadent signature 12 oz. burger is tavern stuffed with crumbly bleu cheese and served on a Costanzo roll
- Turkey Burger$14.95
For those looking for a lighter healthier burger this is your dish. Grilled turkey burger topped with roasted red peppers, asiago, fresh lettuce and tomato
- Grilled Turkey & Brie$15.95
We slice our signature hand-carved turkey and pile it on a fresh Costanzo roll then top with roasted red peppers, fresh lettuce and tomato then grilled ever so slightly to melt the brie
- Beyond Burger (V)$15.95
We perfectly grill the world’s first plant-based burger that looks, cooks, and satisfies like beef without GMOs, soy or gluten served on a fresh Costanzo roll topped with lettuce and tomato
- Swiss Burger$17.95
Our infamous 80/20 CAB Beef grilled to order and topped with sautéed mushrooms and Swiss cheese
For the Kiddos 6
- Grilled Cheese$8.50
- Macaroni and Cheese$8.50
- Spaghetti and Meatballs$8.50
- Cheeseburger$8.50
- Hamburger$8.50
- Chicken Fingers$8.50
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated April 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.